Making Effective Decisions Example at Grade 7
A worked STAR example for Making Effective Decisions at Grade 7, showing a strategic decision with Director-level trade-offs.
**TL;DR.** At Grade 7, Making Effective Decisions is about strategic decisions affecting your function or programme, navigating political sensitivities, and presenting recommendations to Directors or Permanent Secretaries.
Worked Grade 7 example (250 words)
*As Grade 7 policy lead I was asked to decide whether to proceed with a planned regulatory announcement in a politically sensitive week when another government department was announcing a related but unrelated policy. The two announcements in the same week risked confusing stakeholders and giving opposition spokespeople grounds to conflate the two. I had three options: proceed on schedule, delay by two weeks to the next parliamentary session window, or combine with the other department's announcement. I consulted the Director of Regulatory Policy, the press office, and the corresponding Grade 7 in the other department, and reviewed the political calendar for the subsequent four weeks. I identified that a two-week delay would miss a mandatory stakeholder consultation window but that the combination option would require joint approval from both departmental permanent secretaries within 48 hours — unlikely given the timeframe. I recommended proceeding on schedule with a coordinated press handling plan across the two departments, negotiated directly with the other Grade 7. The Director approved. The announcements went on the same day but with clearly distinct messaging, no stakeholder confusion was reported, and both departments received positive press coverage. This evidences Grade 7 Making Effective Decisions: strategic trade-offs, multi-stakeholder consultation, cross-government negotiation, and visible outcome.*
Try SpecMatch — free.
Skip the manual work — let SpecMatch do it for you
Everything in this guide is built into SpecMatch. Import your CV, paste the job, and get a tailored application in minutes.
Try it free — no credit card neededNot ready to sign up? Get free tips instead.
One email a week with application advice that actually works — criteria coverage, STAR examples, and what panels look for. Written for NHS, Civil Service, and local government applicants.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Frequently asked questions
Does Grade 7 Making Effective Decisions require ministerial input?
Not always, but many Grade 7 decisions have a political or ministerial dimension. Strong examples show navigation of those sensitivities — consultation with press office, policy leads in other departments, or Deputy Directors — even if ministers themselves are not directly involved.
How detailed should the Grade 7 decision reasoning be?
Panels score the visibility of your reasoning. A 250-word behaviour example can legitimately spend 150 words on reasoning — options considered, criteria applied, consultation undertaken, recommendation rationale. That is the scoring section.